Lasting Marriage

Home Up Pre-Marital About Marriage Lasting Marriage Infidelity Commitment

 

 

LASTING MARRIAGE:  WHAT ARE THE ODDS, REALLY?

Greg Swenson, Ph.D.

Click on the links below to move to that topic.

  Divorce Rate in the United States

How many times have you heard that the divorce rate in the United States is one out of two? It's a very discouraging statistic. Of course few people getting married plan on divorce, but that ominous figure has to be in the back of their minds. As it turns out, that statistic is not completely accurate, and is misleading. I recently read an article in the summer issue of Marriage Partnership entitled, Don't Believe the Divorce Statistics, by Jim Killam. He points out that the oft-quoted "one-out-of-two" figure seems to have originated from a citation out of the National Center for Health Statistics indicating that the number of divorces nationally in one year is approximately half the number of marriages. It is not based on what happens to marriages that are currently intact. The same article sites a study by George Barna in The Future of the American Family. In his study of 3,142 randomly selected adults, he found that 24% of the married adults had been divorced, a figure that comes closer to measuring the actual prevalence of divorce. Marriages may stand a better than 50% chance of survival. He notes that among people over 55 years old, marriage is actually quite stable. Most divorces occur before the mid-40's.

top

The rate of divorce among young people is higher, and may approach the one-out-of-two figure. The annual ratio of divorces to marriages has been 1:2 for over twenty years. This roughly corresponds to the advent of no-fault divorce in 1970. It occurs to me that it also corresponds to the beginning of an era of increased emphasis on self-satisfaction and diminished respect for the concept of commitment.

top

  Divorce rates among people who identified themselves as "born-again Christians" was 27%; this is higher than the non-Christian rate of 23%! 

The most surprising statistic from the article was from the same study by Barna. How can this be? You might ask. I would suggest several possibilities:

1. The Christian faith is more of a creed or system of belief for many, than it is a way of life.

2. Christians may enter marriage with higher, and sometimes unrealistic, expectations, and have greater difficulty accepting the disappointment when reality sets in. Along the same line, Christians may have lower tolerance for imperfections in their spouse and marriage. Many people have a constricted concept of what constitutes a "Christian marriage". They fail to allow for the difficulties of resolving individual differences, and the struggle of the Spirit with the flesh.

3. Christians may be in denial more than their non-Christian counterparts regarding problems in themselves, their spouses, or their marriages, failing to recognize them until severe problems have developed. Although few people, Christian or otherwise, see divorce as desirable, it may come to be accepted as a lesser evil, compared to being attached to a spouse with "problems", or being part of a struggling marriage. Divorce may function to externalize the problem.

top

  Our culture, including Christians, has relied on tradition as a primary support for the integrity of marriage.

 I suspect that couples didn't get along in daily life better in the past than they do now. But people remained married because they couldn't imagine anything else. Their parents and grandparents were probably married for life. Tradition is not the same as commitment. It isn't strong enough to hold people together in a world where forces of evil assault what is good from within and without. People eventually question traditions, as they are now questioning marriage. They experiment with alternatives, and new traditions develop. Divorce and co-habitation have become common. To some, this is no more significant than the current trends toward eating meals out more often and wearing jeans to work. But I think the loss of marriage as a lifelong commitment is more than a nostalgia issue. I see few forces in our society likely to take a stand for the value of permanent marriage, besides the Christian Church. If we are to do so, we have to differentiate between extrinsic faith (where forms and traditions are preeminent) and intrinsic faith, in which our beliefs dictate how we live our lives. 

top

  If marriage is to be a part of intrinsic faith, a lifelong commitment, what does that mean in practice?

1. We must accept living in conflict with our culture; accept living out of style. Commitment to marriage runs counter to the pursuit of self-satisfaction in many instances.

2. Our marriage must become a chief occupation, rather than just a status. We have to think about our marriage: What is happening between my spouse and I? Are we becoming emotionally distant, or is conflict rising to uncontrollable proportions? What should we do about it? Are we experiencing joy and pleasure together? Marriage requires periodic evaluation.

3. Along with evaluation comes adjustments. When it is clear that adjustment must be made, we have to be willing to do whatever is necessary. That means that sometimes we have to sacrifice something we feel is valuable: possibly a job, time doing something we like, or a relationship. Phrases like, "go for it", and "you have to be happy yourself" have come to represent what people believe in today. Sacrifice isn't a word that you hear a lot. But it is more relevant to marriage as the Bible defines it. I'm reminded of my father, who several years ago decided to end a satisfying and enjoyable career in business to become a full-time caretaker for my mother when she developed serious, chronic health problems. He has never regretted it.

4. Marriages have to be protected. We have to limit, avoid, or give up anything that would threaten the marriage. For some, it may mean giving up golf, going to the bar with single friends, or working with a co-worker who is getting too close. It is easy for other things and relationships to become more attractive than marriage at times. Marriage isn't just loving. It is parenting, paying bills, and caring for property as well, all of which can become mundane and draining.

5. Love for spouse must be developed. Love is an investment in a person. This is best demonstrated by Christ's relationship with people. We must be willing to invest time and effort in our spouse, providing what they need rather than what we want to give them. Love doesn't come so much from the attractiveness of an individual as it does from what you invest in them. Each person has their own unique needs, and we need to know what our spouse's needs are. When people "fall out of love", they have usually stopped investing in their mate.

6. Forgiveness is essential. We inevitably fail and do wrong things. Because of the intensity of the marriage relationship, one spouse can fail another in a big way, and many times over. How often and for how bad a failure should we forgive? How often and for how bad a failure has Christ forgiven us? Of all things necessary for lasting marriage, I believe this is the most critical. We must be willing to recover from hurt without resentment.

top

  God intended marriage to show us our limitations.

Among other things, I think God intended marriage to show us our limitations, make us dependent on him, and to focus our minds on enduring truths rather than the whims of contemporary society. The possibility that maybe more than one out of two marriages still endures is a hopeful realization. Yet, even a 25% failure rate is cause for concern, especially when it appears that younger people must deal with less favorable odds. Perhaps the numbers serve to remind us that marriage is not easy. Marriage is like a long mountain bike race. I never feel like I have mastered a course when I'm done. I am acutely aware of my limitations, my need for sustenance, and I'm thankful that I have finished. Marriages endure or come to an end for reasons. We need to devote ourselves not just to our spouse, but to those things that make marriage last.

 

Dr. Greg Swenson PhD
Copyright © 1997-2003 
All rights reserved.
Revised: April 19, 2009.